What is the true nature of man?
What is the true nature of Man? This is a question that has long preoccupied thinkers and it centres around two central ideas: Man is naturally selfish and competitive or Man is naturally altruistic and cooperative.
In today’s world with wars and crime hitting the headlines daily we could be forgiven for believing that Man is indeed naturally selfish and competitive but an interesting perspective on the subject comes from the 18th Century philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau who believed in the natural goodness of Man but that he is largely influenced by the society in which he is living.
This is really interesting to me because in today’s modern world our economic/political system – neoliberalism – encourages us all to be competitive and self-interested yet many a writer – George Monbiot and Rob Hopkins to name just two – see the way to a better future as using our imaginations to visualise a world where we are co-operative, social and altruistic.
This article will look at the bold progressive ideas that are taking us to a better future. Evidence, perhaps, that the true nature of man is innately altruistic and cooperative?
In fact, Rob Hopkins visualisation of a better way of living, which is beautifully encapsulated in his book ‘What is to What If?’ has led to the very flourishing Transition Town movement. (
I wrote about Transition Towns in February 2019 when I questioned: Is Britain broken? but I think it’s worth repeating that it is ‘A movement of communities coming together to reimagine and rebuild our world.’ I like that because it fits very nicely into Rousseau’s view that the nature of Man is largely influenced by the society in which he is living.
With a government aiming to ‘Build Back Better’ – a nice three-word slogan which doesn’t actually define ‘better’ – there are many people who are thinking we should ‘Build Back Green’ and even ‘Build Back Together!’
Together is a new online initiative which is a coalition that everyone is invited to join, from community groups to some of the UK’s best-known organisations. Their aim is: ‘To bring people together and bridge divides, to help build a kinder, closer and more connected society.’
From July 2020, Together conducted a survey of 150,000 people which looked at their experience of what life was like for them during the pandemic and the findings were really interesting –
- Despite periods of unease, the public responded by strengthening community connections
- Most people got to know their neighbours better
- An overwhelming majority want to keep the benefits of closer communities and build on them
- A massive 12.4 million people volunteered during the pandemic, 4.6 million of them for the first time, of whom 75% would volunteer again
Bishop Nick Baines, chair of the Together trustees said:
“We found a clear public appetite for a society in which we are more connected to each other and the community spirit of 2020 is kept alive.“
Even on the political front, progressive alliances are springing up all over the country as far apart as Bristol, Milton Keynes and Sheffield. Political parties are looking to see what they have in common and are working together to bring about the changes we so desperately need. They are united in their aims to ‘Build Back Green’ and ‘Build Back Together’.
My thinking about this all sprang from the review in Resurgence magazine of a book by Rutger Bregman called ‘Humankind’ which was published early in the pandemic. His video Humankind is especially interesting!
Bregman says:
‘I’ve always believed that crises are big opportunities (for change). There’s that famous Milton Friedman quote that in moments of crisis things depend on the idea that are lying around. I’ve argued that the problem with the 2008 crisis was that we hadn’t done our homework. We knew what we were against but we didn’t know what we are for.’
But Bregman is much more optimistic about the potential for transformative change now thanks to the:
‘rich ecosystem of bold progressive ideas that have taken root in the public debate in the past 20 years.’
From the good news stories I’ve unearthed over the past year or so which have helped me to feel much more optimistic about the future, I reckon his claim that bold progressive ideas have taken root is spot on!
My thanks, as always to Resurgence magazine for many an uplifting read!

This is one of a series of articles by author Eileen Peck, searching out the good news stories to hearten us during these challenging times.