It’s Time to Change Tactics: The War on Drug Addiction Has Failed
The war on drug addiction has failed to effectively combat addiction and has instead fuelled the epidemic of incarceration and recidivism. What we need now is an innovative approach, one that treats addiction as a medical condition and that responds to underlying trauma, rather than treating addiction as a criminal justice problem.
The war on drugs has failed. It is plain and simple. But why do we have a Drug War anyway? For most people, the motivation to use drugs is because they are suffering from some degree of mental or physical ailment linked to trauma. Whether it is childhood trauma, PTSD, or a knee injury, the traumatic experience is what leads to addiction for many people, not the drugs themselves. The answer to any epidemic is not prohibition, it is education and empathy.
Drugs have been used since the beginning of time. From pain relief during surgery to euphoric recreation, there are many ways drugs can be useful, albeit there are concerns that addictive drugs are routinely prescribed long-term by GPs. And yet, many countries see them only as a negative thing and fight a war on drug addiction that has been going on for nearly 70 years.
But how effective has that war been?
There is much evidence suggesting the contrary and some people believe we should focus our resources elsewhere. The problem with addiction is that most addicts are also abusing other parts of their life in order to use drugs. This leads to poor health, job issues, and sometimes crime.
Addiction as a Response to Suffering
Gabor Matè, a renowned physician, speaker, and writer, has seen this in the heroin-addicted men and women he treats at the Eastside Center in Vancouver. Addressing the cause of addiction and treating the condition rehumanises addiction and recognises that drug use or other addictive behaviours affect different people differently in response to suffering, highlighting the role of mental health professionals in treatment.
Matè describes drug addicts as hungry ghosts, referring to one of the six areas of the Buddhist circle of life where we “constantly seek something outside ourselves to curb an insatiable yearning for relief or fulfilment.”
Acknowledging that many people have addictions that cause little or no harm to themselves or to others, Matè confesses that, in addition to being a workaholic, he also has an unusual personal addiction: shopping for classical music! It is an addiction he calls “wearing dainty white gloves” compared to his patients’ harsh drug abuse in the Downtown Eastside.
It also shows why a harm reduction scheme that begins when people engage in addictive behaviour is necessary to effectively treat more problematic drug users. Matè’s view is that although every traumatised child does not become a drug addict, every addict has been a traumatised child, and that locking addicted people up in jail often perpetuates the cycle of abuse and addiction.
Rather than a war on drug addiction, experts such as Matè believe we need a far more compassionate approach to addiction treatment.
Current Treatment Models Work for Some
Since the beginning of time, humans have struggled with bad habits and certain behaviours that they struggle to control. Most agree that anyone who struggles with these problems should receive help, but the focal point of this help has changed over the years. In recent generations, treatment programs have focused on motivation, willpower, and “just saying no.” These treatments work for some, but do not always provide the long-term solution that many need to stay clean and sober.
We need to start helping addicts identify their triggers and emotional states to break free from addiction. Instead of trying to convince people that they do not want a drug or drink, they should be treated like scared little children who just want a safe place to land. There is no cure for addiction, but recovery is possible. Everyone wants a safe place and all we can do is hope they find it.
We use the word “addiction” so freely these days that it has lost much of its meaning. We have addictions to relationships, money, shopping, technology, food and even love. Many people use the term to describe their compulsive need to check their phones every few minutes as though they are expecting an urgent message, or they have a powerful draw towards shoes or handbags. It is easy to mock those who seem to be suffering from a bad case of addiction and think we might never end up like them.
Removing the Stigma of Addiction
People struggling with addiction are not bad people, they are people trying to escape their circumstances. Stripping them of the help they need because of a misconception about the nature of drug use only makes things worse. That is not to say we should “chillax” and drink alcohol all day, but punishing addicts is not going to help them overcome their pain, it will only push them further away from self-care, which is exactly what we, as a society, do not want or need.
So, what can we do to help ourselves, or those we love who are facing a battle with addiction?
We spoke to a leading addiction expert, Paul Spanjar of the Providence Projects drug rehab centre who believes major changes are necessary to help those struggling with addiction:
“Much of the work we do at our facility centres around helping clients find meaning and purpose without the need for taking drugs. Many individuals walk through our doors not knowing who they are, or what bigger purpose they serve. While it is important to follow a programme and remain committed to sobriety, we find most of the healing and transformation occurs when individuals find new meaning and pleasure from daily life, usually in a community-lead setting.”
He added:
“Punishing individuals for their pain is not going to change their minds, serious prison reforms are needed, and better community-lead programmes are needed to give individuals a sense of purpose and responsibility, and most importantly, connectivity. We need to start looking at the root cause of the problem in a broader, societal context. There is so much more we can be doing collectively to identify those who are vulnerable. Prevention and education need to be begin much earlier in an individual’s life.”
