The following shocking information is provided by Cllr. James Abbott of the Essex Green Party:
Waste to be trucked in from outside Essex if residents recycle more.
Two Essex Tory Lords have pledged not to support incineration, yet plans for waste burning plant continue.
At a meeting of Braintree District Council (Scrutiny, 28th January) Essex County Council officers gave a presentation on their proposed Essex Waste PFI bid and Waste Strategy and came under probing questions from a number of District Councillors present, including Green Party Councillor James Abbott.
A particular focus was why the County Council had given planning consents for such large plants in the county (Basildon, Rivenhall and Stanway) when they stated in their presentation that the need was for far less capacity, as a result of the success of recycling in the county. They were also asked what would happen with the plants, if as expected, recycling continued to rise. Essex County Council officers stated that
“waste from other counties will be sought if contracts are not met from within Essex”.
After the meeting, Cllr. James Abbott said “As time goes on we find out more and more about what the County Council really intends with its expensive, centralised waste plants and PFI bid. After this meeting we now know that under the binding contracts they are planning, the more the residents of Essex support recycling, the more waste will be trucked in from outside the county so that these huge waste factories are kept fed.
Last year the County Council held a consultation which was widely criticised for asking questions designed to arrive at the required answers. But in addition, nowhere in that consultation did it explain the intention to bring in waste from outside Essex to keep the waste plants fed. It’s another shocking revelation.
Residents in Essex have been specifically encouraged to recycle to help the environment – which is absolutely right – but now we find out that however much they recycle, waste will still be trucked into and across the county to be mashed up and burnt. That means more HGVs on our roads and more pollution in our air. This is a PFI deal for big business, not residents.”
Following the County Council presentation, the Scrutiny Committee agreed to host an independent presentation on PFI and the proposed waste treatment methods owing to the large numbers of outstanding questions. Members pointed to the financial and planning problems with several large waste PFI schemes, such as Manchester.
The broken pledge on “No incineration”
Green Party Councillors have also uncovered more evidence of the massive breach of public pledges that the Tories in Essex are set to make if they grant consent for the proposed waste incineration plant at Rivenhall Airfield. Not only did Lord Hanningfield, the current Leader of Essex County Council make written election pledges to residents that there would be no incineration in Essex without a referendum, both he and fellow Essex Tory Lord Dixon-Smith (the former Chairman of Essex County Council) made strong pledges in the House of Lords to the same effect (1).
The current planning application for Rivenhall Airfield, in open countryside, includes a waste incineration plant burning up to 400,000 tonnes of mashed up municipal black bag wastes and commercial and industrial wastes, with material coming in from Essex, Eastern Region and possibly London (source: Regulation 19 information from Golder/Gent Fairhead). The plant would run continuously for decades and would produce about 10 million tonnes of carbon dioxide and other gases over its planned lifetime. Waste would have to be delivered under contract to keep the plant fed, contrary to the need to minimise waste and maximise recycling.
Notes:
(1) At the 2001 County Council elections, Tory Lord Hanningfield, the current Leader of Essex County Council pledged that there would be no incineration in Essex and stated, in writing to residents, that if they wanted incineration they should “vote Labour”.
The following year, in the House of Lords, both he and fellow Tory Peer Lord Dixon-Smith (a former County Council Chairman) made strong and clear statements against waste incineration and did not make the distinctions between different types of waste burning that Lord Hanningfield is currently attempting to make: Hansard 17 Dec 2002
Lord Hanningfield:
“We have spent two years trying to get the authorities to agree on the matter within a consortium. The word “incineration” is already engraved on my heart. We have had riots and disturbances as no one in Essex wants incineration. In fact, I have given an undertaking that there will be no incineration without a referendum in our county. Therefore, we are considering different and very expensive methods of disposal, and we hope that modern technology will catch up a little. In many parts of the country, incineration is not acceptable. We need to find different ways to deal with waste and we are trying to speed up technology in order to find methods of doing so.”
Lord Dixon-Smith:
“I completely understand the problem that everyone has with incineration. I, myself, do not like incineration and I do not believe that anyone should build incinerators any more. They simply convert one form of pollution into another form of pollution, and that is not what the business should be about.”
A few years later, the Tory council began a process, which is now reaching a crucial stage, of developing a waste strategy and PFI bid to deliver 2 huge centralised waste plants, producing 200,000 tonnes per annum of material to be burnt and to build a waste incineration plant in Essex to burn it, totally breaking their pledge.
To get around this obvious breach of trust, the Tories have called their incinerator “an energy plant”. Indeed Lord Hanningfield wrote to residents recently making statements about a live planning application at Rivenhall Airfield, despite the legal the risks of doing so, and referred to the “energy plant … proposed at Rivenhall Airfield.” The plant he referred to is a waste incineration facility, as defined in the European Waste Incineration Directive (WID). It would burn up to 400,000 tonnes a year of mashed up black bag municipal wastes, commercial and industrial wastes.
Using the Freedom of Information Act, Green Party Braintree District Councillors discovered that since at least March 2006, the County Council had been in discussions about a waste incineration plant on the airfield. The Council even included the site and waste burning plant in their PFI Outline Business case to DEFRA, having obtained the written agreement of the site owner, now the applicant, for such a plant on the site “for planning purposes”.
For further information, please contact:
Cllr. James Abbott
Essex Green Party Co-ordinator
01376 584576
07951 923073

2 Comments
EFW incinerators don’t work and are past technology for several reasons; 70% “Skyfilling”, no monitoring of unfiltered PM2.5 fine particles, PM2.5 emissions and epidemiologically proven health pathway, especially to infants downwind of 20+ UK incinerators, carbon emissions and physical footprint, energy inefficiency compared to newer alternative best available technologies BAT, plasma gasification or MBT+AS does CHP better, high capital costs and high 25 year gate fees, low jobs creation, conflicts and caps recycling above the 50% threshold level, 10% blight on property prices to 4.5km, problematic landfill requirements of 25% bottom IBA and 5% toxic fly ashes.
Rob Whittle
Vice Chair
NAIL2
Norwich
Norfolk
I was amused by a report last week in the BBC news which said that we could start to turn rubbish into fuel to fuel cars. Turns out only paper and food waste, (which is the least of our problems) can be used in production which then has to be added to petrol to drive the car.
The report was funny because it made out like all rubbish in landfills could be used and this would be an end to us using either bio fuels or petrol, funnier still, I didn’t get the full story till I logged onto Newsround which is for children! Seems like only the children are getting the full information!!!
Last week after my shopping trip to Morrisons, a bag of lentils dropped from my shopping bag, and I noticed that it was not made from recylable packaging, although they stated quite clearly that they “care for the environment” and therefore they were “working on it”….NOT GOOD ENOUGH MORRISONS. I swiftly went back with the bag of lentils and asked in a very loud voice for my money back and when she asked me to fill in the form as to why I was returning the item I wrote in bold capitals that it was not good enough.
I think we should be naming and shaming companies who don’t care enough to use recylable packaging. It has taken me years to source my own packaging and I pay a huge price to make sure that it is recylable, with the least amount of energy to do so.